The Manhattan Club

New York City, New York

The Manhattan Club Reviews & Ratings

« Back to resort

4.5

out of 5
  • 5

    (98)

  • 4

    (29)

  • 3

    (8)

  • 2

    (3)

  • 1

    (4)

  • Resort location
  • Staff/Service
  • Cleanliness
  • Sleep comfort

Been to The Manhattan Club lately?

Add review
  • By dougs65 Feb 18, 2009
    Helpful? 0 0
  • We are happy to note that many of the 2007 complaints have been rectified! The rooms, although they vary in size from quite large to...

    Read more »
    By duffy104 Feb 1, 2009
    Helpful? 0 0
  • We just purchased 3 nights, Dec. 30, 2008 - Jan. 2, 2009, for my parents 50th Wedding Anniversary through rentals at Redweek.com. The...

    Read more »
    By mariae87 Updated Jan 4, 2009
    Helpful? 0 0
  • Nicely located hotel which was the main reason for the stay. Stayed in July on the 16th floor in a 1 BR with a view of the park. Nice...

    Read more »
    By lesleer Aug 13, 2008
    Helpful? 0 0
  • Great location and wonderful suite. Really loved it.

    Read more »
    By carol456 Jul 12, 2008
    Helpful? 0 0
  • Went for a few nights last month and my first stay in a renovated room. Big difference and I'm glad to see that the large increase in...

    Read more »
    By stevens397 Updated May 20, 2015
    Helpful? 0 0
  • The penthouse suites are very luxurious and the size is very appealing compared to a typical hotel room in NYC. We comfortably fit 4...

    Read more »
    By philipaw Jan 26, 2008
    Helpful? 0 0
  • I have been an owner since it's opening, When they became available I upgraded to the penthouse suite. Although there have been...

    Read more »
    By richardm372 Dec 28, 2007
    Helpful? 0 0
  • Best location in New York City!! The size of rooms is about average for the city, small compared to Orlando and other places I've stayed....

    Read more »
    By robertm646 Oct 4, 2007
    Helpful? 0 0
  • Just came back from an RCI trade into this resort. First the positive - location, location, location. That said, here are my negatives -...

    Read more »
    By paul206 Jun 2, 2007
    Helpful? 0 0
  • Our family stayed in this Club for 6 nights in June 2004.This is an outstanding resort, close to all of New York amenities. It is by far...

    Read more »
    By 14639 Updated May 8, 2007
    Helpful? 0 0
  • I recently stayed for the first time. I am a new owner and had my worries because of previous reviews. Arnie and Tiffaney treated us like...

    Read more »
    By byrong4 Apr 10, 2007
    Helpful? 0 0
  • Great location, 3 blocks from central park, 5 from times square. Rented here in March 2007. Great rate for NYC, unit was smaller and not...

    Read more »
    By tracy870 Apr 9, 2007
    Helpful? 0 0
  • By angelaw29 Nov 29, 2006
    Helpful? 0 0
  • We travelled from Australia & have spent 7 days at this wonderful resort. It is situated in a very good location right near Broadway &...

    Read more »
    By di21 Oct 18, 2006
    Helpful? 0 0
  • LOVED this place. Around the corner from Carnegie Hall, 3 blocks from Central Park. Easy access to markets of any kind and the subway....

    Read more »
    By marlene109 Oct 15, 2006
    Helpful? 0 0
  • We have recently came back from a 7 day visit at The Manhattan Club. Very nice location, close to everything, very friendly staff. The...

    Read more »
    By krischarnaw Sep 15, 2006
    Helpful? 0 0
  • This is a great place to stay in NYC. It is near everything. Across from Carnegie Hall and not far from times square. Just a short walk....

    Read more »
    By kathy929 Aug 15, 2006
    Helpful? 0 0
  • Stayed here twice now, Fourth of July week 2005 and Apr 06. Both times in 1 bed/2 bath units - rented from owners. These units are very...

    Read more »
    By onholiday Jul 30, 2006
    Helpful? 0 0
  • We so enjoyed our stay at the club; this is a fabulous location, a wonderful room with compact but convenient amenities, and great...

    Read more »
    By maggyaz Jul 11, 2006
    Helpful? 0 0
  • Just came back from the Easter week vacation at this resort. Great location and service provided. The one bedroom unit is clean, nicely...

    Read more »
    By stephen326 Updated Apr 28, 2006
    Helpful? 0 0
  • Its interesting to note from reading the reviews that the service and accommodations have done "down hill" since the place opened! New...

    Read more »
    By helen73 Apr 25, 2006
    Helpful? 0 0
  • The suites are great. Nicely laid out. Perfect location. Good service! Love it!!

    Read more »
    By shannon221 Apr 23, 2006
    Helpful? 0 0
  • By pseda Apr 8, 2006
    Helpful? 0 0
  • Be Aware!!! There are Mandatory Hospitality Fee that will be collected by the Manhattan Club at check-in. "Guests may pay by credit card...

    Read more »
    By rogerlay Updated Mar 14, 2006
    Helpful? 0 0