I am a SRV owner. I bought sight unseen when two prime winter weeks became available. Having stayed at both 5-star resorts (where one is waited on/hovered over every second) and campgrounds (where the midnight trek to the privy is a l-o-n-g hike,) I felt that this would be a comfortable alternative.
Sunset Ridge Villas have totally lived up to my expectations- and then some!. Somebody made the comment that staying here is actually more like living on St. John. So true!!! There is ample space to invite friends and family and not feel cramped. The master suite is totally private, as are the villas themselves, set with privacy walls between them. There is a full kitchen with all of the amenities that one would expect. There are three bathrooms, so nobody has to wait for one. The courtyard is great for barbecuing and looking at the views. The in-unit washer and dryer are invaluable.
Speaking of the views, they are to die for! We loved watching the boat action in the sound, and the sunsets are stunning. It's also fascinating to watch the cruise ships leaving and/or docking in Charlotte Amalie at night. Yes, you can see that far! From unit E, you can watch the car ferry come from Red Hook. You can also look "down" upon the Westin, LOL.
The pool and common area maintain that stunning view. We enjoyed sitting on the pool deck with other vacationers watching the sunset over a drink. The pool is great--- I was able to swim laps almost every day in the salt-filtrated water.
Apparently, there are now air conditioners in the master bedroom suite. In January, this was not necessary. We enjoyed having the screens open and listening to the tropical rains trickle down in the wee hours... (thinking about our friends and family back home, buried in two feet of snow.) There is a flat-screen TV in the master suite.
My only criticism is that in our units (E and C) there are queen-size beds in the master suite. For those of us who are used to king-size beds at home, this can get uncomfortable.
The world-class beaches on St. John are superb. They are sometimes crowded with cruise ship clients, and parking spots in high season are at a premium. Plan on getting to the beach early, especially on the weekend. Trunk Bay is guarded and has an underwater snorkeling park. Cinnamon Bay is beautiful, crescent-shaped and usually has good snorkeling. Both beaches have full amenities, including showers and refreshments. Other beaches are more primitive. The SRV units are each equipped with beach equipment, so you don't have to pack them, unless you are extremely picky about what you use.
Highly recommended are the National Park Service hikes--- a great way to see the gorgeous interior of St. John. Book early--- even months in advance, as these hikes fill up fast. The one we took has a shuttle ride to the top of a mountain, a hike down to the sugar mill and a deserted beach (trickier than it sounds,) and a boat ride back to town.
It's very convenient to have a car (four-wheel drive absolutely necessary.) Parking at the Villas is tight, but do-able. There are, however, other ways to get about. There is a bus that runs on Centerline Road (you would need to walk up and down the hill to get to/from it) to points unknown about every two hours. There are also the ubiquitous open-air taxis that would be happy to drive you to wherever. Fees are regulated, but understandably expensive.
Speaking of expensive... to spare you sticker shock... be forewarned that groceries are twice as expensive as on the mainland. There are two grocery stores, the Dolphin Market at the roundabout in the center of town, where parking is limited, plus the Starfish Market down the road, which is upscale and extremely expensive, but has ample parking. Plan on paying at least 50% more for gas.
Some traveling tips: the first year we visited St, John, we rented a car from a local rental company. The second time we got one at the Charlotte Amalie airport and drove to Red Hook car ferry. As much as I like to support local businesses, I have to say that the latter was much more convenient and not any more expensive, plus we got an infinitely better (safer?) vehicle. When it came time to take our son back to the airport, it would have been cheaper to take the car ferry back and forth between St. John and St. Thomas, by the time the ferry and taxi fares are paid. If you plan on traveling to St. Croix, the seaplane port is just a few paces from the Charlotte Amalie ferry which is much more convenient than the Red Hook one. This is a passenger ferry that runs erratically to and from St. John, and is ofter booked up on the weekend in season, so plan accordingly.
All in all, with a stay in the Sunset Ridge Villas you can expect comfort, independence, privacy, relaxation, spectacular venues and room for the entire family. Hope you have the opportunity to enjoy it.